I've been carrying this for three weeks and the zipper pouch is the surprise win — coins and my ID stay put without bulking up my pocket. The magnetic flap snaps shut securely, and the detachable strap came in handy when I wanted to go hands-free at the farmers market.
Madison★★★★☆
The leather feels genuinely nice and the magnetic closure snaps shut securely, which I didn't expect at this price. I do wish the card slots were a bit looser since my ID is a tight squeeze, but the detachable lanyard has been handy on walks.